Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sara da Encarnação's avatar

The spine of this story is the human opening and the line 'I did not want him to hear who I was.' That sentence does theology, character, and doom in nine words: he believes enough to hide his name, and steals anyway. The whole tragedy is already in it.

Three suggestions. The creature is over-itemized; horns, feathers, fur, scales, catalogued one by one, and then the genuinely brilliant sentence, 'assembled by a hand that did not know where one should stop,' arrives too late to ignite them. Cut a third of the anatomy and let that sentence do the work. 'Boiling cold' made me stumble rather than shiver; 'the water boiled, and no heat came off it' keeps the wrongness without the contradiction. And Nookomis opens the story, then vanishes from it. Give her one heartbeat inside the drowning, the medicine that will never arrive, and the ending stops merely landing and starts to hurt.

The lock of hair rising toward the sun without him is a superb final image. It deserves that one extra wound beneath it

Alicia's avatar

A very elegant, mysterious story. Beautiful!

22 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?